by Miriam Ellis
Almost exactly three years ago, I published a post here on Search Engine Guide entitled User Reviews As Local Activism. In that piece, I encouraged citizens to make the extra effort to leave good reviews of their favorite locally-owned businesses as a positive form of supporting them in an economy that is often heavily slanted towards corporations and big box stores. Three years ago, reviews were just starting to take on the power that they have today, and at that time, I think I gave only a passing thought to the other side of the coin - the potential for people to leverage negative reviews to promote their personal agendas, both political and otherwise.
Now, having just read articles at Alabama Live and The Huffington Post, I know what the flipside of the coin looks like.
Starting around October 13, small business owner Steve Dubrinsky's Birmingham, Alabama deli became the target of a campaign to inundate his Google Place Page with negative reviews, many of which attack him for allegedly employing illegal immigrants. This must doubtless be considered fallout of Alabama's decision to uphold the strictest immigration laws in the nation. In interviews, Dubrinsky has declared that his workers are legal, but this has not stopped his neighbors from slamming his Google Place Page with hate reviews and threatening his deli with a boycott along these lines:
Within a week of this, there was an onslaught of positive reviews for the deli, most of which simply praise the food and service, but others of which directly speak to the perceived abuse of the review system:
Like many people with even a drop of Indigenous ancestry, I find the specter of relatively recent immigrants making laws about other, newer immigrants to this great land to be darkly ironic. As one Huffington Post commenter put it:
Where'd your people come from? You got legal papers from my Native American people giving you the legal right to be here? Seems that maybe it's you who needs to pack up and head back to the fatherland�, hombre.
I will also make no bones about the fact that, given the United States' bleak history of conquest, enslavement and never-ending civil rights violations, I absolutely loathe any law or language that hinges on race. Sit yourself down and read Barry Estabrook's Tomatoland, a book about the enslavement of Hispanic Americans in the ag fields of Florida happening right now, as I type this article, and you will realize that this country has yet to leave its worst ideas behind. Gives me the creeps, to say the least.
But, from a purely Local perspective, I'm writing about this issue today at Search Engine Guide because it calls so strongly into question the role review hubs like Google, Yelp, TripAdvisor and the like will be called upon to play in the online publishing world in which sets of stars and blank fields will be taken for a soapbox by many users. This is what I'm hoping we can discuss in the comments.
Google's Review Posting Guidelines make this statement (italics mine):
Keep it real
People read reviews to learn about real experiences from real people, so be authentic. Keep your reviews to your own, direct experience with a place. Try to describe your experience as accurately as possible, including both positive and negative aspects. Off-topic reviews
Reviews should describe your personal, first hand experience with a specific place. Please do not post reviews based on someone else's experience, or that are not about the specific place you are reviewing. Reviews are not a forum for personal attacks, rants or crusades. Please also do not use reviews to report incorrect information about a place -- use the Report a problem link for that place instead.
Even without the article in a high level publication like The Huffington Post, some type of flag will likely have gone up in Google's system as a result of a single business gaining pages and pages of reviews over the course of a single week. Let's hope the deli's supporters don't run into a goofy Google spam filter based on review velocity that might actually lead to a penalization of the whole listing. I feel this case is well worth watching because I do believe Google will have to take some sort of steps regarding the very large number of reviews left this month for this business that would most certainly fall under the heading 'personal attacks, rants or crusades'.
For comparison, look at Max's Delicatessen's Yelp Profile and you will absolutely no sign of political controversy. It's an odd day when a small business has only 16 reviews at Yelp, but 182 on Google! Has Yelp, with their sometimes infamously stringent review policy, already kicked in behind the scenes, erasing the aura of controversy? They certainly have the right to do so, given their guidelines, and I am watching to see what Google will do.
And finally, I think this brings up a related issue that is worthy of discussion and debate. Local news sites, local blogs, local review hubs...the unifying quality of all of these is that they strive to paint an accurate picture of local communities.
If, like most communities, yours is unfortunate enough to be inhabited by its measure of certain citizens who are comfortable using racial epithets and who are likewise comfortable making public attacks of a racial nature on local businesses...this is an accurate picture of your community. If a humble delicatessen in the South becomes a political batteground, and online communities delete all references to what is happening there, how informed and true is the online version of our world? How accurate is the index?
The dozens of politically-motivated Occupy Wall Street reviews continue to sit on the Google Place Page of Zuccotti Park in NYC. Despite being an evident violation of Google's guidelines, they occupy most of the Place Page's review space. A creative use of the medium, perhaps, but is it right?
In so many ways, the Internet is a champion of free speech, enabling us to communicate our views and to encounter the views of others in ways never dreamed of before. But when it comes to hate speech - and the advent of this concept of the 'hate review' - where do we stand?
I hope you'll weigh in with your thoughts on this interesting development in the world of online reviews. Should review entities remove reviews that do not center on a customer's actual patronage of a given business, landmark or site? And, if such data is removed, does this make the picture of the business more or less accurate, on the whole? Finally, what should a business owner like Steve Dubrinsky do, finding himself in the middle of this online reputation attack? Respond to the reviews? Hire a lawyer? Sue the portals that are enabling this content to be published about his buisness? What's your take?
.Be sure and visit our small business news site.
Source: http://www.searchengineguide.com/miriam-ellis/google-reviews-as-political-battleground.php
link popularity link exchange pay per click ppc experts social media
Use These Tips And Be A Better Internet Marketer
ReplyDeleteIt is a well known fact that Internet marketing is tough work. It's also work that you need to approach effectively in order to reap the true financial rewards. You definitely don't want to overwork while approaching things the wrong way. The tips listed here will get you going in the right direction.
Technology moves fast, and if your company wants to keep up, you are going to have to take advantage of all the technology available for marketing success. If your customers use more advanced software than you do, they will wonder why you haven't upgraded. If you adopt new technologies quickly, you will present a better image to your customers.
Always stay on top of what your internet marketing competition is doing. It does not matter what industry you are a part of, there will always be competitors.
Internet marketing is both similar to, and different from, other marketing tactics. For example, you may find that search engines are no longer paying attention to your title tags. If this happens, you may need to put more work into other venues, like viral video marketing.
Use Internet marketing to effectively increase your profits. With the advice listed here, all of your hard work will pay off.
How To Make Internet Marketing Easy, Fun And Fruitful
ReplyDeleteIt is a well known fact that there are no short cuts and easy way outs when it comes to internet marketing. It is also true that your hard work must be done right to be effective. There isn't any point in working hard in the wrong direction. The tips below will provide you understand how to use the right direction and make more money.
If you belong to message boards, put the link in your signature, which will make it appear with every post you make. This is a non-aggressive way to promote your business without actively having to "talk it up" to others.
Your website tags should very clearly define your site.
Provide one thing that is niche or very unique on your website.This will likely be a very effective means of traffic to your pages.
Use internal links that link to other areas on your keywords. Internal linking helps people stay on your page for longer periods of time and can provide you more hits from other advertising avenues.
Direct marketing can be an effective part of you Internet marketing campaign.Contact customers by fax, phone, or fax to tell them about services and specials.
As you've read, it's vital to put any effort into Internet marketing campaign that has you heading in the correct direction with it. Use the advice you've just been given to take your business to the next level.
At A Loss With Internet Marketing? Begin Here With This Solid Advice
ReplyDeleteInternet marketing can help your products or services get their site noticed online. It may seem simple, but you have to become educated on the topic of internet marketing in order to succeed at it. The powerful advice in the article below will give you on your way to becoming an expert in Internet marketing.
Internet marketing means taking advantage of every possible software advancement in modern technology. If your company fails at using technology, the competition could leave you in the dust. Show them that you know about new innovations, and they will respect your products and decisions.
You need to create a great site before you can attempt to get it ranked. This must be your first step in starting a web-based business. If you have a good website, good you will not have to change it as much over time.
Get people to click ads by creating links to the product you sell. This will not look like a traditional advertisement.
You can then identify which version is best by checking the number of new subscribers.
Internet marketing is an ever-changing phenomenon and research. Many of these same people will advise you personally for a fee. You should thoroughly research your endeavor before deciding it is something you can hold onto easily.
Give a variety of choices to people when they check-out.You could give a special promotion to previous customers.
Tips To Make Your Business Visible In The Social Media World
ReplyDeleteMarketing in social media is a new and promising way that businesses can market themselves. By using social media sites to their full potential, a business will be able to better promote their services and products.
To start off successfully in social media marketing, until you find your own voice, simply fake it until you make it. Have a look at what your competition is doing in this field, and then copy it until you have figured out what best works for you. Look up their social profiles, the type of specials they have, and the messages that they post.
Rome wasn't built in a day, and neither will your social media presence. It is not likely that you will wake up tomorrow morning with a few thousand new followers. Some profiles on the social media sites will go viral quickly, but this should not be expected as it is not the norm. If you are patient and diligent, success will happen.
As you know, companies are continuing to successfully market themselves through social media sites. With social media, just a little time or money can go a long way. Social media is incredibly popular, and will be even more so in the future. Do not miss out on this opportunity by utilizing the techniques shared in this article. They will help your business grow and become more profitable.
Tips To Make Social Media Marketing Easier
ReplyDeleteThink about using social media marketing as an advertising alternative that will boost your monthly stats. Sometimes, a fresh approach is all you need to enjoy renewed success. Utilizing social media marketing has several advantages. It is inexpensive, easy to use, and can help you reach a large audience. This article will outline several simple steps you can take when you start a social media marketing campaign.
Post new blog content frequently and with regularity. When you have new information and your visitors are expecting new content, they will often come by to see what you have up. This is also the truth when people subscribe to other publications. Be sure you stay consistent so that visitors want to come back.
Be careful if you are considering using a marketing company for social media. Unfortunately, a number of these firms have fraudulent schemes running and they prey on the inexperience of others.
As you can now see, beginning a marketing campaign using social media is not difficult. Once you take those initial steps, staying up-to-date on new technologies will keep you relevant and profitable. You will only see a return on this type of marketing with consistent effort, so follow the above advice and schedule time to update your profiles regularly.
Considering Social Media Marketing? These Tips Could Help
ReplyDeleteYou can use social media sites to do some very effective marketing, not just to keep up with your family and friends or play games. Social media networks will not work if you do not use the right techniques. Keep reading to find out how social networks can be used to develop your business.
Social media marketing works better with large followings, so always invite everyone you see and know to join. Even if they don't subscribe or follow your page, they're at least being made aware of your company's presence.
Try using YouTube as part of the marketing you use for social media, to help attract specific viewers to your website. YouTube is effective in drawing in newer visitors, since watching your video content should familiarize them with your products and services. If more new visitors reach your website after viewing your YouTube videos, they will have more knowledge about your products and potentially complete more purchases.
In order to assist your site in becoming social media interactive, add comments and ratings. In addition, you should have the ability to be able to sort out items. When you add these popular functions, you empower your users to help choose your content and direct your efforts. They will appreciate the opportunity to participate actively.